Paper or …

I know; I’ve discussed this before. In gory detail. You are probably sick of my endless discussion of our national supermarket habit and the reams of plastic it seems to require. But I think ridding ourselves of our plastic bag habit is an easy change to make, one that doesn’t require the kind of wide scale reconfiguration that addressing our car habit would take (though on that issue — carpools, bikes, and your own two feet are all great options). Besides, it’s in the news this week.

The Connecticut legislature is considering a ban on plastic bags, according to David Funkhouser’s recent piece in the Hartford Courant. I was pleasantly surprised to see that people here are at least supportive of the idea, though I wasn’t entirely satisfied with the way the article was written. There’s no discussion at all of countries that have been charging for plastic bags for years (Germany, for example), and only a cursory mention of Ireland, which started taxing plastic bags a while ago and seems to have survived the transition. Elisabeth Rosenthal wrote a piece on Ireland’s bag tax back in February that actually seemed to suggest that the decreased use of bags has been a positive thing for initially reluctant retailers — an interesting point that seems to have been overlooked in the Courant’s piece.

Maybe an outright ban is too much of a change for people in this country. But the assertion that recycling is an equally good alternative to finding ways to decrease the use of plastic bags is not going to help anyone. It takes energy to recycle bags, and it takes initiative on the part of the consumer to bring those bags back in — all of which could have been avoided if a plastic bag hadn’t been handed out in the first place. I’m not saying they’re not useful to have around the house sometimes, and I’m also willing to acknowledge that even I forget to bring mine along on occasion. But really, taking a reusable bag along hasn’t been a difficult change to make, and I think once people stop resisting any change that might possibly be of the slightest inconvenience to them, we might actually have a country I could be proud of.

Advertisements

3 Comments

Filed under environment

3 responses to “Paper or …

  1. Yeah, there are a lot of things people could be doing to make stuff better.

  2. So, my friend started this company:
    http://www.trolleybasketusa.com/

    Peter is Swedish by nationality, saw the baskets in a Swedish magazine and wondered why they weren’t being imported to the US. It’s a great alternative to paper bags because if a store carries the baskets: you can buy them to take home with you… I’m excited because I just got a sample basket from him to use at Nica’s/Edge of the Woods/Bishops…hopefully the stores will pick up the idea and purchase baskets from his company…

  3. liz

    Sweet — hope it catches on. It seems like something smaller stores (ie, Edge of the Woods) would go for — full sized trolleys just seem to cause total chaos in there! And we usually use our reusable bags as carts already, just so we don’t have to carry them in addition to a basket, so this would make things easier…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s